Date: Saturday 18 April 2015
Participants (from 10 countries)
China: Miranda, Haru, Dora, Yi Chen, Qiuqiu, Alina, Trista | Tunisia: Amine | India: Sunita | Egypt: Mohamed, Anas | Spain: Oscar | Bangladesh: Mohammad | USA: Rick | Hong Kong: Selly | Argentina: Johny | Pakistan: Eshaal | Colombia: Sandra
Team A: (Yes) Miranda, Haru, Dora, Amine, Sunita
Team B: (No) Mohamed, Anas, Oscar, Yi Chen, Qiuqiu, Alina, Mohammad, Rick
Team C: (On the fence) Trista, Selly, Johny
Others that briefly joined: Eshaal, Sandra
Moderator: N/A
Team A Summary:
- Grammar provides the basic foundation, gives confidence when speaking. Knowing the rules of grammar are more important in other languages (other than English) where there may be more rules and considerations
- Grammar provides the structure and meaning of the sentence
- Like building a home, you need to lay the foundation, and grammar is like the mother of language
- Without knowing grammar, a person cannot communicate effectively
- Knowing the grammar is important to pass exams
- In a business environment, or in other specific areas, especially if you are writing correspondence etc., it is very important to have great grammar skills in order to be credible and professional
Team B Summary:
- Unless a person is studying to become a linguistics expert, it’s not as important to emphasize the grammar
- One of the participants said his grandmother was illiterate, she could not read or write, but because of her conversational skills, she was able to still be functional in society
- The ability to communicate in a company is very important, even if it is verbal communication
- Young children learn communication skills before they learn grammar
- Basic grammar is important, but communication is more important (except for teachers or people providing lectures etc.)
Team C Summary:
- It depends on why you are learning the language
- In India, more than 60% speak English but the quality is very important
Trista= Team B
Selly= Team B
Johny= Undecided
Team B won the Debate
Below is the link to listen to our chat:
- Studying grammar is more important than conversation skills - Voice chat recording file 1
- Studying grammar is more important than conversation skills - Voice chat recording file 2
For people who did not join the live discussion, feel free to contribute the ideas in comment blanks below.